Understanding Negative Carry Trade Losses in Japan

Welcome! I’d like to shed some light on an issue garnering attention in the world of finance and real estate investing. Recently, financial headlines globally highlighted the troublesome financial state of a Japanese bank—observers have rushed to tie this to an investment in long-term securities vis-à-vis the inversion of the yield curve. However, despite commentary from major outlets like Wall Street Journal and Bloomberg, there seems to be misunderstanding or misreporting of the actual problems.

A Deeper Dive Into The Issue

The issue here involves Norinchukin Bank, an agricultural financial institution in Japan that provides services to the forestry, farming, and fisheries industries. The Bank, which doesn’t rely heavily on a standard loan portfolio for its income source, is reportedly selling more than 10 trillion yen or $63 billion of its US and European government bonds holdings by the end of their financial year in March 2025. This decision, as reported, aims to curtail the losses resulting from low yield foreign bonds’ investments, which have ostensibly triggered an imbalance in the bank’s finances. But is this only the problem?

Breaking Down The Carry Trade

This strategy is often referred to as a carry trade, where an entity borrows in one currency at low-interest rates to fund an investment in another currency that provides higher returns. At the end of March, Norinchukin Bank’s foreign bonds amounted to around 23 trillion yen, constituting about 42 percent of its 56 trillion yen total assets. These investments were made due to the lower interest rates in Japan compared to foreign markets.

Herein lies the real challenge. Despite the mainstream media suggesting otherwise, the problem isn’t primarily because of the falling bond prices due to rising interest rates; in fact, holding on to these bonds until maturity wouldn’t cause any loss. The real problem is the rising cost of short-term interest rates, which has proven higher than the yields from bonds in their balance sheet, resulting in a negative cash-flow situation for the bank.

Checklist for Understanding Financial Crisis
Understand the bank’s strategy and portfolio
Analyze the interest rate scenario in the bank’s operation territories
Examine the implications of various financial strategies like carry trade
Assess the potential risks and losses
Consider mainstream media interpretations with caution

What’s the Future?

Interestingly, the issue isn’t only confined to Norinchukin Bank. Major banks in Japan are exposed to similar situations regarding foreign carry trades. These institutions have, like Norinchukin Bank, resorted to foreign investments to seek higher yield given the low-interest rates in Japan. Consequently, any further financial distress could potentially cascade across other banks in the country. What remains to be seen is if changes in short-term interest rates can alleviate these difficulties or whether these institutions will need to sell assets at a loss to limber up.

Stay connected and discover more about my work in real estate and by visiting and following me on various platforms:

Real Estate Espresso Podcast:

Y Street Capital: